Winsor and Newton – Cotman Water Color Paints 24 Whole Pan Studio Set

I am a great one for mulling over things that I must buy; especially the expensive ones. Art supplies in India are so dear that buying them is nothing short of a small investment. So, instead of  the supremely expensive Winsor and Newton artist’s watercolor set, one must settle for the student variety Winsor and Newton Cotman 24 whole pan watercolor set, which is relatively cheaper. After doing a reckie of all the online art supplies stores, I was overjoyed to find that the Himalaya Art Supply site was offering the product I chose at Rs 1500/- less than Amazon or on SnapDeal (Snapdeal also has a sort of Chinese Winsor and Newton that is as cheap as Camel – can’t figure that out). So, after months of dithering and wondering what to do, I decided to go for the Himalaya Art Supply offer.

Guess what, after  I placed the order and made the online payment I was informed that the price was actually the same as that as that on Amazon and it had been a mistake in their updating system. Why would I pay the same price for a product on which they would then charge Rs 450/- as delivery charges and then take 14 working days to deliver, which comes to almost 3 weeks, when Amazon would deliver it free of cost on the third day. In high dungeon, I cancelled my order and went back to opening the product everyday and looking at it with lovelorn eyes. I mean, its like when you screw up your courage to do something distasteful and it fizzles out, doing it a second time is not easier.

Well, one Sunday I was whiling away the time by clicking on my wishlist items on and almost received a heart attack when I saw the watercolor set going for almost 50% off! I blinked my eyes, refreshed the page twice, checked on Hubby’s laptop to be sure and then ordered. Received it the next day!

And then began the unveiling.

I was a bit disconcerted to find that the pans were not individually wrapped as in the earlier model and suffered a pang of fear that it was a bogus product. Hubby ensures me that Amazon would never deal in bogus products and as I tend to trust him in such matters, I decided to do so with this too. Also, I decided to put up an extremely detailed account of my Watercolor pan set so that someone can tell me whether I have been duped or it is the real thing!


The box is not as smart as the older one, but the paint box inside seems to be the same as that shown in videos of the Winsor and Newton Cotman sets. All the pans were wrapped in cellophane like little candy treats. They do look adorable lined up like that don’t they?

In many reviews, people had warned that the pans were not fitted to the bottom and were prone to falling out when you travelled with them. They suggested gluing the pans onto the box. I smirked and thought how worrisome these firangs were and since I won’t be doing any Plien air painting I had no need for such frivolous advice. I should have known better. While I was trying out the colors, I had a sketch taped to my board waiting for its paints. Engrossed in my new colors, I put my arm over the paint box, managed to get the wet Ivory Black pan stuck to it, and even as I raised my arm to look at it watched it fall face down onto my sketch. Thankfully, it fell on a part that was supposed to be a log and therefore the work could be salvaged. An inch above and I would have had to make a new sketch. Always pay attention to reviews from people who definitely know better.


Here you see the cellophane wrapped pans. The name of the color contained in the pan is printed on the side of each one for which I was extremely thankful. The Winsor and Newton logo is stamped on the bottom of each pan. The pans themselves are made of lightweight plastic and seem a bit too flimsy, but then I guess in a bid to make their product as cheap as possible they used cheap materials for the containers. Well, as long as they didn’t compromise on the colors who cares!


This was a color chart contained in the box. It is a small leaflet, again very different from the one shown in the older boxes. In the lower picture I have marked the colors that are present in this box. It just makes me feel wonderful that I have so many of them.

There are 3 shades of yellow, 4 of red, 4 of blue and 2 of green. I really wish they would have added one more green in place of the extra Cadmiun red deep hue. Greens are so difficult to get right anyway and are used so abundantly all the time. Just a humble suggestion.


I made a color swatch to make it easy to identify the colors in the box (hasn’t photographed well). Its very amateurish but it has been a big help in picking up the colors correctly. I realised that these colors have a more transparent quality than the Camel ones I was using and somehow seem brighter. They do however have a tendency to stick to my watercolor brush bristles. Maybe its just what all very good colors do because my Camel colors never did feel sticky. Whatever it maybe, I love the box and the tiny little pans and the beautiful colors.



8 thoughts on “Winsor and Newton – Cotman Water Color Paints 24 Whole Pan Studio Set

  1. Looks legit 🙂 I have a similar little box, but for 12 colours only.
    Also regarding the paint pans being loose, I actually think they are supposed to be loose, so that if a pan runs out of paint, then you can replace only this one pan, instead of buying a whole new set. Also, it gives you the option change any colours if you were wish to do so.
    I wouldn’t glue them, so that they never get loose again, but if you do wish to keep them in place, then maybe rather use two-sided sticky cello-tape? I never glued mine, and while I remember one coming out of the box half way a few times, it never bothered me enough to start gluing things and I’ve had the box for 7-8 years, granted I do use Winsor and Newtons a little less frequently these days and have a liking for some strong Russian brand (also with loose pans), but still the loose pans never seemed so much of a problem. Also, I think it’s also a matter of where you place the open box compared to your hand movement.

    Happy painting, looking forward to your future paintings! 🙂


    1. Thank you for the endorsement. And you are right I figured I won’t be gluing them to the pan, instead as you point out, will try to place the box at a safer distance from my hands 🙂 Which paints are you using?


      1. I’m currently mostly working with a brand called Nevskaja Palitra: Sonnet – or I think that’s what’s written on the box, it’s all in Cyrillic as they’re produced in Russia and I’m not so proficient with reading Cyrillic shrift. They feel to me as if they have a little stronger pigment than Newton&Windsor, but N&W are very good also, no complaints really. I think you’ll enjoy using N&W very much 🙂


      2. Thank you. You are right in that the W&N colors are more transparent and light. I found that difference immediately from the local brands I was using. But they are supposed to have better light fastness or so I hope. Time will tell! But enjoying myself for sure!


      3. Ah, yes, you are right W&N does not fade that much. At least not when exposed to direct sunlight. If you want to hang your paintings on the wall, then maybe some protection will be needed… Since I don’t hang any on my walls these days, then I keep my experiments in a folder out of reach of sun and dust. Even paintings done 6-7 years ago with W&N still have good colour and have not faded one bit.


      4. Hmmmm. But then what is the use if the same applies to my cheaper watercolors! And my better watercolors are all on my walls! O Well Time will tell whether these W&N colors are any better! 🙂


      5. Yes, it’s difficult to tell before you haven’t tried hanging one on the wall.. I wish you luck anyways. Hope the colours will not fade!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s